Jump to Recipe
Homemade roasted red peppers are one of those simple kitchen staples that can make everyday meals taste richer, sweeter, and more savory. They pair beautifully with cheese, which is why I love adding them to grilled cheese sandwiches, mac and cheese, and creamy nacho sauce. Their mellow roasted flavor also blends easily into pasta sauce, pizza sauce, dips, and spreads. They are just as good tucked into sandwiches, layered on toast, or served alongside a simple meal as a flavorful side.
I have always enjoyed using roasted red peppers in recipes, but for a long time I relied on store-bought jars. They are convenient, but once I started roasting red bell peppers at home, the difference was obvious. Homemade roasted peppers taste fresher, sweeter, and more vibrant. The texture is tender without feeling dull, and the flavor is clean because you control exactly what goes into the jar. With just red bell peppers and olive oil, you can make a small batch that is ready to use throughout the week.
Should you buy organic peppers?
I do not insist that every fruit and vegetable has to be organic, especially when organic produce costs much more than conventional produce. It is not always practical or necessary for every grocery trip. That being said, bell peppers are commonly included on the Dirty Dozen list, which means pesticide residues are frequently detected on them. If you are taking the time to make oven-roasted red peppers at home, buying organic red bell peppers can be a worthwhile choice when it fits your budget.
Choose peppers that feel firm and heavy for their size, with smooth, glossy skin. Since the peppers are roasted whole, you do not need to do much preparation beyond washing and drying them well. Dry peppers roast more evenly and allow the skins to blister properly in the oven.
Making roasted red peppers
Roasting red bell peppers is mostly hands-off. Place the whole peppers on a sheet pan and roast them in a hot oven at 450 F for about 40 minutes, turning them once halfway through. As they roast, the skins will blister, darken, and char in spots. That charred skin is exactly what makes the peeling process easier and gives the peppers their deep roasted flavor.
When the peppers come out of the oven, immediately transfer them to an airtight glass container. If you do not have a suitable container, a ziplock bag can also work. Let the peppers rest and cool until they are comfortable to handle. This resting time traps steam around the peppers, loosening the skins so they slip off easily with your fingers.
Once the peppers are cool enough to touch, peel away the blistered skins. Tear the peppers open and remove the stems and seeds. Do not rinse the peppers under water. Rinsing may seem like an easy way to remove stray seeds, but it also washes away the flavorful juices that make homemade roasted peppers so delicious. A few seeds left behind are not a big problem, so focus on preserving the taste.
Storage tips
To store homemade roasted red peppers, stack the peeled pepper pieces in a pint-size mason jar. Drizzle olive oil between the layers as you add them, then top the peppers with enough olive oil to cover them. Keep the jar in the refrigerator and use the roasted peppers within 1 to 2 weeks.
The olive oil helps keep the peppers tender and adds flavor. After the peppers are gone, do not waste the remaining oil. It will have absorbed some of the roasted pepper flavor and can be used in simple dishes such as pizza, focaccia, hummus, or other recipes where a little savory olive oil would be welcome. This makes the whole batch feel even more useful and prevents good oil from being thrown away.
These homemade roasted red peppers are easy to keep on hand and can quickly upgrade meals that need a little sweetness, color, and depth. Add them to sauces, blend them into dips, layer them in sandwiches, or serve them as a simple side dish. Once you make them at home, it is hard not to notice how fresh and flavorful they are compared with many store-bought jars.
Homemade Roasted Red Peppers
Roasting red peppers at home is simple, mostly hands-off, and gives you fresh, flavorful peppers that are perfect for sandwiches, sauces, dips, and side dishes.
Side Dish
American
roasted red peppers
15
minutes
40
minutes
4
roasted peppers
whiteblankspace
Ingredients
-
4
red bell peppers - olive oil
Instructions
-
Position a rack in the middle of the oven and preheat the oven to 450 F.
-
Place the whole red bell peppers on a sheet pan. If you line the baking sheet with parchment paper, check that the parchment is rated for the oven temperature.
-
Roast for 40 minutes, turning the peppers once halfway through. The skins should become blistered and charred in spots.
-
Transfer the hot peppers to an airtight glass container and let them cool until they are easy to handle. A ziplock bag can be used if you do not have a suitable container.
-
Do not rinse the peppers. Peel off the skins with your fingers, then tear the peppers open and discard the stems and seeds.
-
Stack the roasted peppers in a pint-size mason jar, drizzling olive oil between the pieces. Top the peppers with olive oil and store in the refrigerator.